Can a laser kill an insect? The physics in four numbers
Killing an insect with light sounds like science fiction, but the physics is simple heating. The question is how much energy it takes, and whether a small drone can deliver it. The answer: a few joules, a third of a second, and almost no electricity.
Number one: 52 °C
Insects are cold-blooded and small; heat their head and nervous system above about 52 °C and they die. Our model uses that threshold and nothing gentler. Laboratory studies on the Colorado potato beetle show that even repeated exposure to 35 to 39 °C for a few hours a day already costs it more than half of its egg production. A short, hard burst well above that is lethal.
Number two: 3.5 joules
We take a deliberately pessimistic target: 7 cubic millimetres of water, more than the whole beetle head, heated from 22 °C to 52 °C.
E = m · c · ΔT = 0.007 g × 4.18 J/(g·K) × 30 K ≈ 0.9 J absorbed
Not all of the light is absorbed. Measurements made with the photonics team of the Vrije Universiteit Brussel show that at 1550 nm the beetle's shell absorbs about a quarter of the light on the first pass. So the laser has to deliver about 0.9 / 0.25 ≈ 3.5 joules. In reality the spot chars black within milliseconds, which raises the absorption; the model ignores that bonus.
Number three: a third of a second
With a 10 watt laser, 3.5 joules take about 0.35 seconds. A hunting drone hovers about one second over each target to settle, aim, fire and check the hit, so the laser needs only part of that second. More power simply makes the shot shorter; on the bench, 50 watts of focused light charred an adult beetle.
The hard part is not the energy but the aiming: the beam has to stay on a head about a millimetre wide while the drone sways in the wind. A small fast mirror (a MEMS mirror, as used in some phone projectors) steers the beam, and a camera loop corrects it hundreds of times a second. Our simulations keep the beam on a 1 milliradian target more than 99 % of the time.
Energy per kill is one of the narrated, interactive chapters on photonicinsecticides.com: 3D scenes, real drone footage and every number traced to the study it comes from.
Number four: about 1 kWh per hectare per year
Because each shot is so small, energy hardly matters. All the drone flying for a hectare in a year, scouting and hunting together, uses about 1.1 kWh: the electricity of a light bulb for a few days. The cost of a laser-drone flight hour is almost entirely the hardware, not the power (see what control costs per hectare).
Why 1550 nanometres?
- Water absorbs it. That is what heats the insect, and it is also what protects the human eye: the water in the front of the eye absorbs this wavelength before it can reach the retina. See eye-safe lasers at 1550 nm.
- The parts exist. 1550 nm is a telecom and lidar wavelength, so compact, efficient laser diodes and optics are widely available.
Other wavelengths work too: a laser cart for beetles uses an Er:YAG laser at 2.94 µm, and laser weeders use powerful lasers in the open field today. The challenge for a drone is weight, which is why the design is built around a small laser and a few joules per shot.
Sources
- Kill model: photonicinsecticides.com published models (llms.txt): 7 mm³ of water heated 22→52 °C, 25 % absorbed at 1550 nm.
- Absorption spectra of the Colorado potato beetle per body part: VUB photonics team with Flanders Make, funded by PhotonHub Europe (Horizon 2020 grant 101016665).
- Liao et al. (2022). Effects of repeated short-term heat exposure on life history traits of Colorado potato beetle. Insects 13, 455.
- Pantec Biosolutions: LaserFly, an Er:YAG 2.94 µm laser module for agritech.