Why the Colorado potato beetle beats insecticides
Few pests have outrun chemistry as completely as the Colorado potato beetle. It has become resistant to 56 insecticide compounds, from the arsenic sprays of the nineteenth century to the neonicotinoids of the 1990s. For growers, every new product has had a shelf life.
A beetle built for resistance
Resistance is evolution under pressure, and this beetle evolves fast for three reasons.
- Many offspring. A female lays several hundred eggs: about 316 at 27 °C in laboratory studies, and close to 400 in summer populations at 21 °C. A spray that kills 99 % of a population still leaves survivors that can rebuild it within one season.
- Repeated exposure. Potatoes are sprayed two or three times a season against the beetle, often with the same product year after year. Every spray selects for the individuals that survive it.
- An appetite for toxic plants. The beetle lives on potato and wild nightshades, plants full of defensive chemicals. Its detoxification enzymes were tuned for that long before insecticides existed, and they turn out to work on many of them too.
The mechanisms are the usual ones, often stacked: enzymes that break the insecticide down faster, a changed target site where the insecticide no longer binds, and a cuticle that lets less of it in.
One class after another
Arsenical sprays came first, then DDT after the Second World War, then organophosphates, carbamates and pyrethroids. Each worked for a while; each met resistance somewhere. The neonicotinoids, introduced in the 1990s, were the last broad, cheap answer, and resistant populations appeared within years in North America and Europe.
In Europe the neonicotinoids are now largely gone for a different reason: their risk to bees. Imidacloprid, clothianidin and thiamethoxam have been banned outdoors since 2018, and since a 2023 ruling of the EU Court of Justice member states may no longer grant emergency exemptions for seeds treated with them. Growers are left with fewer modes of action, which makes each of them wear out faster.
Why now: resistance, bans and the move away from sprays is one of the narrated, interactive chapters on photonicinsecticides.com: 3D scenes, real drone footage and every number traced to the study it comes from.
What still works: resistance management
Resistance cannot be avoided, but it can be slowed. The advice from extension services and reviews is consistent:
- Rotate modes of action. Never use the same insecticide group on consecutive generations. The IRAC group number on the label is the thing to rotate, not the brand.
- Spray only when needed, and at the right moment. Young larvae are far easier to kill than adults. Use thresholds and scouting, not the calendar.
- Rotate fields far. Most overwintered beetles walk into the new field from where potatoes grew last year. Studies found that a few hundred metres to a kilometre of distance cuts colonisation, and the need to spray, sharply.
- Use non-chemical tools alongside. Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. tenebrionis, trap crops, trenches and mulch reduce the number of sprays, and with it the selection pressure. Our article on organic control goes through them.
A control method with no mode of action to resist
There is another way out: kill the beetle by something it cannot detoxify. A laser drone finds each beetle and larva in the field and heats it to 52 °C in a fraction of a second. There is no molecule to break down and no receptor to change. The honest caveat: insects can still adapt in behaviour, for example by hiding under leaves. Our models therefore assume that only part of the beetles are visible on each patrol, and the drones return every two days.
The narrated presentation on photonicinsecticides.com shows how that works, what it costs per hectare, and why it is safe for people and pollinators.
Sources
- Kadoić Balaško M. et al. (2020). Modern techniques in Colorado potato beetle control and resistance management: history review and future perspectives. Insects 11, 581.
- Alyokhin A. et al. (2008). Colorado potato beetle resistance to insecticides. American Journal of Potato Research 85, 395–413.
- Liao et al. (2022), Insects 13, 455 (fecundity at 27 °C); Xu & Long (1995), J. Entomol. Soc. Brit. Columbia 92, 73 (summer females).
- Court of Justice of the EU, case C-162/21 (2023), on emergency authorisations for neonicotinoid-treated seed.
- Weisz et al. (1994, 1996); Sexson & Wyman (2005): crop rotation distance and colonisation.