What Colorado potato beetle control costs per hectare
How much does it cost to keep the Colorado potato beetle out of a hectare of potatoes? It depends on the method, and the differences are large: from about 50 to over 1,000 euros per hectare per season.
Chemical control: about 70 euros per hectare per season
A conventional European grower sprays two or three times a season against the beetle. German planning values put one insecticide treatment at about 29 euros per hectare, product and pass included. Two or three passes come to roughly 70 euros per hectare per season. In the eastern United States, where resistance forced more sprays and more expensive products, control has long cost more: between 138 and 368 dollars per hectare, according to figures attributed to Grafius (1997).
That price is rising for reasons that do not show on the invoice: resistance shortens the life of every product (see why the beetle beats insecticides), and the main neonicotinoids have been banned outdoors in Europe since 2018.
Biological control: 300 to 500 euros
Biological insecticides such as Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. tenebrionis or spinosad, applied more often and with tighter timing, cost far more per season: in the range of 300 to 500 euros per hectare. For organic growers there is often no cheaper alternative.
Laser carts: around 1,000 euros
Laser weeding machines prove that lasers work in open fields. But a laser cart is expensive. A machine like Carbon Robotics' LaserWeeder costs around two million euros. Written off over seven years at 300 hectares a year, with a tractor, diesel and two operators for three passes, that is about 1,070 euros per hectare per season. Even if the cart drove itself, the machine alone would still cost almost 900 euros.
Cost per hectare, built up step by step is one of the narrated, interactive chapters on photonicinsecticides.com: 3D scenes, real drone footage and every number traced to the study it comes from.
Laser drones: about 51 euros per hectare per year
Our models put a service with small drones at about 51 euros per hectare per year, averaged over five years on a modelled 10 ha field in Flanders. That is two kinds of drones, each written off over five seasons:
| price with dock | per flight hour | per ha per year | |
|---|---|---|---|
| scout drones (small camera drones, every 2 days) | €800 | €1.79 | €32 |
| laser drones (hunt the beetles found) | €3,200 | €10.36 | €19 |
| total | €51 |
Most of the cost is hardware written off over the calendar, not energy: a year of flying uses about 1.1 kWh per hectare. The first year is the most expensive one, because that is when the beetle population is knocked down; after that the laser drones have far less to do.
How much it varies
The result depends mostly on beetle pressure and on how well the scout camera spots beetles. Across the nine scenarios we simulated, the five-year average runs from about 42 to 123 euros per hectare per year:
| recognition | low pressure | moderate | high |
|---|---|---|---|
| low (30 % of beetles spotted) | €53 | €69 | €123 |
| medium (53 %) | €43 | €51 | €77 |
| high (90 %) | €42 | €48 | €73 |
In the medium scenario about 98 % fewer beetles return the next year, which is why later years cost so little.
What does your field cost?
Averages hide the most important variable: how many beetles your field has, and where. If you have a scouting heat map of your field, from AgroScout or any other service, you can upload a screenshot and get the cost per hectare for one pass in about a minute: open the heat-map calculator. Our article from heat map to cost explains the method.
Sources and assumptions
- Sachsen BPS planning values: insecticide treatment against the Colorado potato beetle, €29 per treatment.
- Grafius (1997), as cited by Growing Produce: control costs of $138–368 per ha in the eastern US.
- Laser cart: list price, depreciation, tractor, diesel and labour as in our cart-versus-drone model (photonicinsecticides.com).
- Laser drones: season simulation (Agrelation development engine, Roeselare weather), fleet sizing and depreciation; all formulas in llms.txt and the public models repository.
- These are model estimates, not quotes.