Laser weeders, laser carts and laser drones compared
Lasers have left the laboratory and entered the field. Laser weeding machines kill weeds in commercial vegetable fields, and investors have put well over a hundred million dollars into the idea. So why not drive a laser cart through a potato field to kill beetles?
Laser weeding is real today
Carbon Robotics' LaserWeeder, a tractor-drawn implement with class 4 lasers and cameras, kills weeds day and night; the company raised a 70 million dollar Series D in 2024, bringing its total to about 157 million. Chinese makers sell all-weather laser weeding robots with several 240 W lasers. These machines prove two things: computer vision can find small targets in a crop, and lasers can be used in the open air under sensible rules.
Beetles are not weeds
A weed stands still in the soil, in a predictable place between the rows. A Colorado potato beetle sits on the plant, often under a leaf, and moves. A potato canopy closes over the rows within weeks, so a machine running between the rows sees the plants from the side, not from above. And a beetle population needs patrolling every few days, all season long, not one or two passes.
The cost of a cart
A laser weeding machine costs around two million euros. Written off over seven years at 300 hectares a year, with a tractor, diesel and two operators for three passes a season, that is about 1,070 euros per hectare per season. Without the tractor, diesel and operators, a self-driving cart would still cost almost 900 euros, because the machine is so expensive. A dedicated beetle laser cart exists too: the Pantec LaserFly, with an Er:YAG laser module at 2.94 µm.
Why not a laser cart? is one of the narrated, interactive chapters on photonicinsecticides.com: 3D scenes, real drone footage and every number traced to the study it comes from.
The weight spiral, and the soil
Heavy machines in a potato field carry hidden costs. Wheels damage the plants: a 1948 study already measured yield losses from 10 % to over 50 % in rows run over by sprayer and tractor wheels. They compact the soil, which costs yield for years (estimates around €30 per hectare per year). And a heavy machine needs a heavy frame, stronger motors, more power, more weight: a spiral that makes everything bigger and more expensive. Every pass is also a chance to spread diseases between fields.
Small drones: light, cheap, many
A laser drone weighs about half a kilo and needs only a few joules per beetle: 3.5 J, a third of a second of a 10 W laser. It flies over the canopy, looks down on the plants and touches nothing. Small camera drones of a few hundred euros scout; laser drones of about €3,200 with their dock hunt. No operator, no tractor, almost no energy: our models put it at about 51 euros per hectare per year, some 21 times cheaper than an operated cart and 17 times cheaper than a driverless one.
| laser cart | laser drones | |
|---|---|---|
| cost per ha per season | ≈ €900–1,070 | ≈ €51 |
| contact with the crop | wheels in the field | none |
| view of the beetles | from the side, between rows | from above, plant by plant |
| laser power per unit | hundreds of watts | about 10 W |
| service | a heavy machine to transport and repair | cheap parts, swapped at a dock |
The honest risks
Drones have their own challenges. The beam must stay on a target about a millimetre wide while the drone sways in the wind; beetles hidden under leaves must be caught on a later patrol; and flying lasers need regulatory approval. The narrated presentation goes through each risk with numbers, including what happens when fewer beetles are visible: open the risks chapter.
Sources
- Carbon Robotics: LaserWeeder product page; Series D announcement, Business Wire (21 October 2024).
- HGTECH all-weather AI laser weeding robot (4 × 240 W).
- Pantec Biosolutions: LaserFly, Er:YAG 2.94 µm laser module.
- Yield reduction from vine injury caused by sprayer and tractor wheels (1948), American Potato Journal.
- Compaction losses in European agriculture, Environmental Research Letters.
- Cart and drone costs: photonicinsecticides.com cart-versus-drone model (llms.txt).